Manifesto Without a Party

Smarter Public Spending

"Use it or lose it" budgeting punishes efficiency and creates 20–40% March-madness spikes. A few simple rule changes could save tens of billions a year without touching frontline services.

The full chapter

Read the full text from the Manifesto Without A Party

Every point above is taken from the unabridged chapter below.

Smarter Public Spending

Across the UK, public bodies are trapped in a rigid 'use it or lose it' budgeting system. This approach encourages waste, punishes efficiency and forces short-term decisions that cost taxpayers money and weaken frontline delivery. The UK loses tens of billions every year through inefficiency, poor procurement and the 20–40% end of year spending spikes this system creates.

The scale of waste

CategoryAnnual estimateSource
Inefficiency and poor value£10–£20bnNational Audit Office
Procurement overpayment£5–£8bnIndependent bodies
End-of-year 'March madness' spikes1–5% of budgetsInternational research
Major project overruns£1–£3bnGovernment reports
Fraud and error (tax, benefits, procurement)£29.5bnGov't estimate 2022–23

UK departments routinely show 20–40% spikes in March spending. International research suggests this behaviour typically wastes 1–5% of annual budgets — driven by the fear of losing future funding if money is not spent.

A better way to handle public money

  • Central Efficiency Pot: all genuine underspends are placed into a central pot at year end instead of being lost. Efficiency becomes a strength, not a liability.

  • Weighted Right to Reclaim: any organisation that contributed to the pot receives priority when bidding for funds the following year.

  • No Penalty for Underspending: baseline budgets cannot be cut simply because money was saved. Responsible management is rewarded.

  • Anti-March Madness Safeguard: no organisation may spend more than a set proportion of its annual budget in the final month without a value-for-money review.

A SIMPLE PRINCIPLE

Public money should be spent wisely, not hastily. This is a productivity transformation, not a cuts programme — protecting frontline services while eliminating structural waste.

Sources & References

All statistics and claims are backed by verifiable sources

  1. National Audit Office – Value for Money Reports

    £10–£20bn/year avoidable inefficiencies.

    https://www.nao.org.uk

  2. HM Treasury – Government Efficiency Framework 2025

    £14bn target by 2028–29.

    https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/government-efficiency-framework

  3. Institute for Government – Civil Service Statistics

    Departmental spending patterns.

    https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk

  4. OECD – Public Financial Management

    International budgeting comparisons.

    https://www.oecd.org/governance/budgeting

  5. Public Accounts Committee – Reports on Government Spending

    Parliamentary scrutiny of waste and efficiency.

    https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/127/public-accounts-committee

Newsletter

Stay in the loop

Get campaign updates, petition milestones, and ways to help — straight to your inbox. No spam, ever.

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe anytime.